Despite Costco’s “down” year, Jim Cramer is urging investors to stick with the company, one of the world’s largest retailers. “If you really want to oppose Costco, give them another funeral notice,” Jim said on Friday’s show “Squawk on the Street.” His sharp comments came after the bell Thursday, a day after Costco reported strong financial results for the first quarter of fiscal 2026. The retailer saw strong sales and bottom line growth due to increased membership fees, increased net sales, and healthy profits. But the stock fell about 0.8% on Friday, indicating the positive news wasn’t enough to sway investors. The main issue was a decline in membership renewal rates, which suggested a slight slowdown. The reason for the decline is clear. This quarter “has to be perfect at that multiple,” Jim explained, noting Costco’s historically premium price-to-earnings ratio currently stands at about 43 times. “What happens is if you’re perfect and you’re not that perfect, people want to sell,” he explained. Costco has had a strong membership fee model for many years, resulting in predictable and high profit margins. Members continue to resonate with Costco’s value proposition of buying in bulk at discounted prices, which allows Costco to perform well in both good and uncertain economic conditions. However, recently there have been noticeable signs of consumer disengagement. Costco’s U.S. sales rose 5.8% in November, excluding gasoline and currency fluctuations, reflecting a sharp slowdown from October’s 6.4% increase. While the company’s results remain strong, investors are having a hard time reconciling its stock’s high valuation and market performance with this year’s “so-so” quarterly results, especially given the outperformance of rival Walmart. America’s largest retailer has emerged as the best-performing company in 2025. This is also leading to a rise in stock prices. Walmart stock is up 27% since the beginning of the year, while Costco stock is down about 3.6% over the same period. “This is a good year for Walmart and it deserves a premium multiple, and this is a year for Costco to do well,” Cramer said. Still, he added, Costco’s fundamental business is strong and the stock continues to have “significant upside.” “We own it, we have owned it forever and we will continue to own it,” Jim said. (Jim Cramer’s Charitable Trust is expensive. See here for a complete list of stocks.)
