Marievit Luna – CNBC | Getty Images
Congress has six years to enact changes to Social Security to prevent cuts to retirement benefits. The senators elected in the Nov. 3 midterm elections will be sworn into office when the deadline expires, and their decisions could be important in enacting tax changes that could affect Social Security.
During the midterm elections, tax policy surfaced in two different ways in the debate over Social Security. Many Democrats and some Republicans called for high-income earners to pay more Social Security payroll taxes, while many Republicans touted recently enacted tax credits for adults 65 and older.
The strategic divergence comes at a critical time for reform. The first strategy has the potential to increase the revenue flowing into the program. Second, it reduces income taxes for the program by reducing income taxes for eligible seniors and allowing some beneficiaries to pay less taxes on their Social Security benefits.
The Social Security Administration Board’s latest projections show that the trust funds used to pay retirement benefits could begin to be depleted in 2032, at which point 78% of benefits will be paid.
Lawmakers have some leeway. Combined, the program’s retirement and disability trust funds would be depleted until 2034, at which point 83% of scheduled benefits would be paid. But this is still a haircut for retirees, and that’s coming soon.
“We’ve already waited too long and inequality is widening,” said Shai Akabas, vice president for economic policy at the Bipartisan Policy Center, about the Social Security shortfall.
During the campaign, midterm candidates largely avoided details about how they would reform Social Security. But raising the payroll tax cap, also known as the maximum levy, was a popular choice among Democratic candidates. This would require anyone earning above the current $184,500 cap to begin contributing payroll taxes on income above that amount.
Meanwhile, some Republican candidates announced they would extend the temporary senior tax credit of up to $6,000 per eligible person, which is set to expire in 2028.
The deduction, part of the One Big Beautiful Bill law passed last July and claimed as a senior bonus, was one of the factors that accelerated the Social Security Commissioner’s projected depletion of the retirement trust fund by three months, according to an annual report released in June.
Experts say anything could happen now that Democrats have a majority in both chambers of Congress.
Tax increase for high income earners
Social Security is a pay-as-you-go system that relies on payroll taxes from workers to help pay monthly benefits to millions of Americans.
In 2026, up to $184,500 of earnings will be subject to that tax. Workers and employers each pay 6.2% of their wages up to that threshold, and the self-employed pay 12.4%.
The wage cap will rise to $192,300 in 2027. It is adjusted higher each year to reflect gradual changes in the average wage index.
During the campaign, some House and Senate candidates argued that the cap should be raised or eliminated entirely to allow high-income earners to donate more.
Sen. Bernie Sanders (R-Vt.), who will become the next Social Security subcommittee chairman after the election, said on TV Show X on Nov. 7 that his proposal to increase benefits by at least $2,400 a year and “remove the cap” on income subject to Social Security taxes would be a “top priority.”
Outgoing Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-Louisiana) told X that the plan would impose a “12.4% tax” on people who are not millionaires or billionaires.
The idea of raising payroll taxes has broader support. A national survey conducted in February found that most respondents (79%) supported increasing taxes on wages over $400,000, according to the University of Maryland School of Public Policy. This change was the most popular choice among the 2,509 adults surveyed.
Rising income inequality means that the payroll tax cap no longer covers 90% of income, a percentage that was expected to remain constant when lawmakers enacted the last major overhaul of the program in 1983, according to a study by the Roosevelt Institute, a New York-based liberal think tank. According to the institute, the share of Social Security payroll taxes in income fell to about 83% in 2000, but is now more or less stable at that level.
Although candidates have mentioned plans to change the cap during the campaign, some experts say Congress could hold off on potentially politically unpopular tax increases.
“Lawmakers may bring some of these taxes on the table closer to 2032, when the Social Security Trust Fund is in bankruptcy,” said Jessica Riedl, a fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, which provides independent analysis of tax issues. “In Washington, we like to wait until the last moment.”

If the payroll tax cap were raised from just under $200,000 a year to $300,000, people in that higher income threshold would pay about $6,700 more in direct payroll taxes, Riedl said.
“Neither party has any interest in this type of tax increase in the short term,” Riedl said. But in the long term, “everything is on the table,” she says.
While many Democrats are pushing for such tax increases, some Republicans have also expressed openness to raising taxes.
“There’s a crack in the dam there,” Dan Adcock, director of government relations and policy for the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare, said of the Republican support.
Even if lawmakers raise or eliminate the cap, they would need to agree on other changes to strengthen the program. Adcock said Republicans may want to cut benefits, such as raising the retirement age, in exchange for higher taxes.
The extent to which tax caps can be adjusted to solve Social Security’s funding problem will depend on how they are applied.
According to a September analysis by the Social Security Administration, 58% of long-term actuarial balances over 75 years would be wiped out if the cap is lifted starting in 2027, with the full 12.4% tax applied to all earnings and no benefit deductions for earnings above the current threshold.
A 12.4% payroll tax rate on incomes above $250,000 starting in 2027 could cover 57% of long-term income, unless benefits are increased in exchange for additional contributions, the SSA said.
According to the agency’s analysis, applying a 12.4% payroll tax rate to incomes above $400,000 starting in 2027 without benefit increases would eliminate 53% of long-term actuarial balances.
Eventually, all income will be subject to Social Security payroll taxes, as the gap between the annual tax cap and the new threshold narrows over time.
But some experts say raising the payroll tax cap could have an impact on taxpayers and the economy.
William McBride, chief economist at the Tax Foundation, an independent tax policy research institute, said the cap increase would be an “unprecedented increase” in marginal tax rates.
McBride said raising the threshold could increase the cost of earning an additional dollar in wages by more than 12 percentage points. These increased costs could have an impact on the labor market, he said, and the unemployment rate could rise as a result of the changes.
“There is no tax on social security.”
OBBBA’s new senior citizen tax credit of up to $6,000 per individual (called the “Senior Bonus Supplement Amount” in an earlier version of the bill) is in effect for tax years 2025 through 2028.
Lawmakers elected to Congress in the midterm elections may decide whether to extend the interim tax cuts.
“2028 will be a presidential election year, and I don’t think either party will allow senior tax cuts to expire while competing for senior votes,” Riedl said.
When President Donald Trump signed the OBBBA Act of 2025, the White House said in a release, “Tax exemption for Social Security is real.” However, the new law does not eliminate taxes on Social Security benefits.
Instead, it provides a deduction that reduces a senior’s taxable income, regardless of whether the senior has applied for Social Security benefits.
During the campaign, Republicans touted the $6,000 senior citizen credit as a tax cut and criticized Democrats who voted against the law that enacted it. But Congressional Democrats unanimously opposed OBBBA, citing provisions such as cuts to Medicaid and food assistance.
The Tax Foundation’s McBride said some effects of the new $6,000 senior citizen credit are different from those of eliminating the tax on benefits. McBride said the senior tax credit would have a greater impact on low- and moderate-income taxpayers, while eliminating taxes on Social Security benefits would be more beneficial to higher-income taxpayers.
How social security benefits are currently taxed
Individuals with total income between $25,000 and $34,000 (adjusted gross income, tax-free interest, and one-half of their annual Social Security benefits) pay federal taxes on up to 50% of their Social Security benefits. For individuals with total income over $34,000, up to 85% of their Social Security benefits are subject to federal income tax.
For married couples filing jointly with combined income between $32,000 and $44,000, up to 50% of their Social Security benefits are subject to federal income tax. Benefits increase by up to 85% for couples with combined incomes of more than $44,000.
The senior bonus tax credit allows you to deduct up to $6,000 for individuals and $12,000 for married couples if you are 65 or older. The deduction is phased out for modified adjusted gross income above $75,000 for single filers and $150,000 for married couples.
The senior bonus deduction, when combined with the 2025 standard deduction of $15,750 for single taxpayers and $31,500 for married couples, and the existing senior deduction of $2,000 for singles and $3,200 for married couples for those who qualify, “represents the largest tax reduction in history for senior Americans,” the White House announced in July 2025. The standard deduction for 2026 is $16,100 for singles and $32,200 for married couples.
Under OBBBA, 88% of beneficiaries, or 51.4 million people age 65 and older who receive Social Security income, will receive exemptions or deductions in excess of their taxable Social Security income, according to the administration. Before this law was enacted, 64 percent of beneficiaries, or 37.2 million people, received tax breaks that exceeded their taxable Social Security income.
However, this measure does nothing to solve the problem of depleted social security.
In its annual report released in June, Social Security’s Board of Governors said OBBBA has a “significant impact” on the program’s financial health because beneficiaries pay less income taxes on benefits. In its report, the trustees moved the projected depletion date for the program’s retirement trust fund to the fourth quarter of 2032, one quarter earlier than the previous year’s forecast.
“This new deduction for seniors will reduce some of the money into the trust fund, which will bring the payment deadline a little closer,” McBride said. “It makes the program a little more vulnerable, so to speak.”
