Artificial intelligence is about to take over the economy. The Fed is bracing for the impact.
“We are at a turning point in the U.S. economy,” Federal Reserve Chairman Kevin Warsh said Monday at a conference in San Francisco. But it’s still unclear when and how the economy will improve, and what that means for interest rates and inflation.
At a meeting of Mr. Warsh’s AI task force, the new Fed chair publicly asked questions that Americans would ultimately expect Americans to answer. He hinted at some personal thoughts about whether white-collar workers could soon face mass job losses, but left much of the speculation to the large number of experts he has assembled to advise the Fed.
With advances in technology, Warsh won’t be able to put off providing his own answer any longer. AI Labs Anthropic is set to price its shares in an initial public offering on Wednesday that could raise up to $64 billion at a valuation of $1.4 trillion. The Federal Reserve is considering raising interest rates in December to slow inflation as the technology sector heats up the economy following massive spending by AI companies.
Americans, on the other hand, are dissatisfied with some aspects of technology. In the Nov. 3 midterm elections, voters enacted a series of state-level measures to slow construction of data centers essential to advancing AI.
Warsh moderated three of the four sessions at Monday’s event and was involved in selecting the speakers. Among them was one of the few prominent Democrats who actively opposed that anti-data center trend.
Gina Raimondo said it was a “very worrying sign” that so many anti-data center measures were passed in the midterm elections. She is a former Secretary of Commerce under President Joe Biden and a former Governor of Rhode Island.
Blocking AI “would be very bad for the United States and for the people who voted for that measure,” Raimondo said.
Mr. Warsh would not say whether he shares that view, and it is not clear exactly how it will be reflected in monetary policy.
This event was an unusual one for the Fed. Central banks employ a small army of Ph.D. An economist who can quickly weigh everything that affects the U.S. and global economy. But Warsh chose to draw on expertise from outside the Fed to consider how to think about the impact of AI on productivity and employment, given his long criticism of the central bank as insular and outdated.
Mr. Warsh formed a special committee on the issue, along with four others focused on aspects of Fed policymaking.
The public heard Monday from venture capitalist Marc Andreessen, one of the three official members of the task force. Mr. Warsh attended Stanford University with Mr. Andreessen’s wife, and the two have been friends for many years. Another task force member, Stanford University economist Chad Jones, is on leave from work at Anthropic and was unavailable to speak during the company’s pre-IPO blackout. A third person, Xbox CEO Asha Sharma, did not attend the event.
Andreessen is very optimistic about the potential of AI as a technology, but he believes the government will never allow Americans to experience its full effects. He said strict regulations in sectors such as health care and education mean technology cannot replace the jobs of people in these fields.
“As long as our economy remains a free market economy, we may well see the very rapid evacuation scenario that people are talking about,” Andreessen said. “But we have largely banned the utopian career moves that doomers talk about.”
Mr. Warsh repeatedly returned to one economic scenario based on past experience. The so-called China Shock occurred after the country joined the World Trade Organization in 2001 and made a major shift toward low-cost manufacturing. For example, Americans experienced rapidly declining prices for clothing and furniture, but at the cost of severe job losses. One widely cited estimate is that the United States lost 1 million manufacturing jobs in the years that followed, or 2.4 million jobs overall.
Warsh suggested to one of the panelists that the spread of AI could create its own version of the China Shock, this time focusing on service workers.
“I don’t want to hold this too tightly,” Warsh said. “But if over the past generation or a generation and a half, the China Shock, in a sense, has, for lack of a better word, lowered the prices of goods in the United States, when I hear you talk about this new technology philosophy, that might do something for services.”
In other words, AI can perform legal and administrative tasks more cheaply than humans, for example. This may bring down prices, but many people will lose their jobs.
Warsh asked the panel: “Should we expect disinflation in the medium term given the potential that AI brings to services?”
They primarily suggest that is possible, which could mean the Fed may eventually want to cut rates in the long term.
But ultimately, it’s Mr. Warsh and his fellow Fed members who need to be sure of the answer.
There are still many steps between the special committee’s discussions and the Fed’s policy changes. First, the three members of the task force must summarize their views in a report to Warsh in the coming months. The Fed would then need to discuss the results itself and decide whether or how to use them to shape monetary policy.
But AI is getting bigger by the day, and the Fed may need to make a decision sooner rather than later.
