vienna, austriaReuters —
Five European countries announced plans on Monday to send rejected asylum seekers to deportation hubs in Rwanda, drawing condemnation from rights groups for putting vulnerable people at risk of abuse.
Kigali said that under the proposed plan (which is still being negotiated with Rwanda), Germany, Austria, Greece, Denmark and the Netherlands would send people to centers where migrants could choose to return home, settle, or go somewhere else where they would have the right to stay.
“This will be a game-changer and will allow us to tackle the huge challenge of illegal immigration,” Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen told a press conference in Vienna, along with her Austrian counterpart and ministers from other countries.
Officials said the five countries have been working for months on an agreement on so-called return hubs, part of a broader effort within the European Union to curb rising deportations and irregular migration.
As elections approach in several EU countries, centrist governments are tightening immigration policies to counter growing public support for far-right parties.
In a joint statement, 47 aid groups, trade unions and rights groups called on the five countries to abandon the Rwanda plan, echoing criticism of different migrant settlement plans between the UK and Rwanda in the early 2020s.
A statement from the International Rescue Committee, the Dutch Refugee Council and other groups said the plan “suggests that member states accept the risk of serious human rights violations against one of society’s most marginalized groups, in exchange for deterrence goals that the evidence clearly suggests cannot be achieved.”
Officials say such hubs can only accept about 100 people at a time, but countries supporting the hubs say it sends an important signal they hope will deter would-be migrants from making the often dangerous journey to Europe.
The project follows the approval of new EU return rules aimed at speeding up deportations.
The plan differs from Britain’s abandoned Rwanda expulsion plan in that it only applies to migrants who have exhausted all legal avenues to remain in the European Union, rather than those whose applications are in the process of being processed.
Rwanda is happy to host
Rwanda has positioned itself as a destination for migrants that Western countries want to exclude, despite long-standing concerns about the country’s human rights record.
Rwanda’s Interior Minister Vincent Biruta said on Monday: “Under this partnership, Rwanda will offer a second chance to people who have lost their legal right to remain in partner countries.”
Rwanda is not seeking remuneration for the arrangement, but partner countries will cover the costs of relocation and integration of those who choose to remain in Rwanda, he added.
President Paul Kagame, a military veteran, helped end the 1994 Rwandan genocide and rebuild the East African country as an investment destination, winning praise from Western countries and regional leaders.
But critics have accused the government of supporting rebel groups who are said to have suppressed dissent and committed murder, rape and other abuses in the neighboring Democratic Republic of Congo. Rights advocates also point to restrictions on political freedoms and free speech.
Freedom House rates it as “not free,” citing what it says is the suppression of political dissent through surveillance, intimidation, arbitrary detention, and torture.
“With limited scrutiny of the Rwanda deal, there is a real risk that it will become a cruel black hole for human rights,” Amnesty International said in a statement on Monday.
The United States began deporting migrants to Rwanda last year under a deal that allows up to 250 people to be deported.
Britain abandoned its own plan to send asylum seekers to Rwanda in 2023 after it was ruled illegal by Rwanda’s Supreme Court. Kigali asked for a payment of 50 million pounds ($63.6 million) after the British plan was scrapped.
Two members of the European Parliament who visited Kigali in September were shown hotels and other facilities that could house migrants deported from EU countries, earmarked for a scheme abandoned by Britain.
