Iran’s control over the Strait of Hormuz is waning, and experts warn that a cornered country is more likely to choose escalation than surrender.
Oil is leaking again even as Iran continues to attack ships in the waterway, undermining the influence it has wielded over the United States since the start of the war. Now, as US President Donald Trump ramps up economic pressure aimed at forcing concessions on the Islamic Republic, Iran may be looking for a way to break the stalemate.
Iran shook global energy markets early in the conflict by effectively shutting down a maritime chokepoint through which a fifth of the world’s oil passed before the war. Oil prices have soared globally, and some economists have warned of a global recession if the shutdowns continue.
Rising energy costs are seen as a key factor in the Republican Party’s landslide defeat in this month’s midterm elections, with American consumers being offered higher prices at gas stations. Trump himself acknowledged that the war was partly to blame for his party’s defeat.
But a global recession never materialized. Oil exports from the region are now approaching pre-war levels, and there may soon be more crude on the world market than is needed. For Iran, that’s a problem.
Nevertheless, Iranian officials claim victory and argue that Iran’s blockade of the strait has already yielded significant strategic benefits. Mohsen Rezaei, Chairman of Iran’s Supreme Council for National Security, said that Iran wants to impose a high price on the American people for an attack on Iran, which will act as a deterrent.
Experts say one of Iran’s key wartime strategies to put pressure on global energy markets may now be losing its effectiveness.
Danny Sitrinowitz, a senior fellow at the Israel Institute for National Security Studies, said the Iranian government has long sought to “internationalize” its war spending. But “if oil prices continue to fall despite Iran’s attacks, that key part of that strategy becomes less effective,” he told CNN.
Oil prices have fallen sharply in recent weeks despite Iran’s escalating attacks on ships in the Strait of Hormuz.
The International Energy Agency attributes this to a recovery in Gulf exports, with oil supplies expected to exceed demand in the fourth quarter for the first time since the Iran war broke out in February.
“Iran is certainly either unwilling or unable to stop the oil spill at this point,” David Oxley, chief climate and commodity economist at consultancy Capital Economics, told CNN, adding that “the navigability of the strait remains far below pre-crisis standards.”
Alia Roshanbakhti, head of fuel desk at Axis Limited, the Middle East’s largest energy liquidity provider, said Iran may be losing some control over the waterway, but the potential for significant damage to the region’s energy infrastructure remains a concern.
Iranian experts say that at this point in the conflict, Iran is unlikely to weaken its demands, but rather escalate military operations to break the “neither war nor peace” impasse with the United States that has crippled Iran’s economy.
Trita Parsi, executive vice president of the Quincy Institute for Responsible Politics, celebrated the Republican loss, saying the Iranian government seems more confident than ever after President Trump’s midterm setbacks.
However, oil prices fell after the interim results as fears that President Trump would reignite the war eased and the Iranian government stepped up diplomacy with mediators.
“A return to full-scale war is unlikely and markets increasingly seem to be assuming that oil supplies will gradually recover,” Hamidreza Azizi, a senior Iran analyst at the International Crisis Group think tank, told CNN.
“However, that assumption could change quickly if Iran decides to escalate the conflict.”
Iran appears to be already considering other options to pressure the United States to return to the negotiating table, and such an event could play out.
Experts say further threats from the United States could force Iran to take more aggressive steps, which would be costly for both sides.
After a period of relative calm, the conflict has rapidly escalated in recent days. The region has seen a series of back-and-forth attacks on Gulf states by Iran and Yemen’s Houthi rebels, as well as U.S. attacks on Iranian territory around the Straits.
Recognizing the possibility of surrender or military escalation, Iran’s hardline regime is likely to choose the latter, even at the cost, experts say.
“Feeling cornered can make you more aggressive, rather than less aggressive,” Citrinowicz said.
Azizi, of the International Crisis Group, said Iran may choose to use the U.S.-backed Strait of Hormuz route to increase pressure on the tanker. He said it could also choose to disrupt oil ship-to-ship transfers or target Gulf infrastructure or alternative export routes that allow Gulf states to circumvent some of the Iranian government’s restrictions in Hormuz.
The Iranian government also appears to be lowering its standards for retaliation. The Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC) announced on Tuesday that it had targeted a US radar in Bahrain following an unspecified “violation of Iranian airspace by a US drone.” He also warned Bahrain’s Sunni rulers against mistreatment of the majority Shiite population.
Iran has warned countries not to allow the United States to use its territory for attacks. National Security Secretary Rezaei said last week that “all military bases from West Asia to Europe would be legitimate targets.”
“There will be no safe distance or safe haven for the invaders,” he warned, adding that “no base will be exempt.”
This not only indicates that Iran may be looking to expand its operational reach, but also now “shows that even a violation of airspace can trigger an attack on U.S. assets,” Azizi said.
Some believe there is not much else the Islamic Republic can do to get Washington to agree to a deal favorable to Iran.
Parsi, of the Quincy Institute, said further actions by Iran will not make a difference. He said the one thing that could make a difference is one thing Iranians don’t want to do: give Trump a “symbolic” victory that “appeases his ego and saves face.”
He said Iranians were more opposed to symbolic losses than real ones, which would only worsen the stalemate.
Meanwhile, the U.S. Carrier Strike Group 3 recently entered the territory of U.S. Central Command and is expected to take part, at least temporarily, in ongoing operations, including enforcing the blockade of Iranian ports and escorting commercial ships wishing to transit the strait.
Experts said the US government may have misjudged Iran’s breaking point.
Azizi said the Iranian government’s recent operations fit into a “broader shift in the Iranian military’s mindset toward more active deterrence.”
“If the leadership concludes that its influence in Hormuz is weakening while the U.S. blockade continues to impose economic costs, it could go further and challenge the U.S. Navy more directly,” he said.
This would be quite risky, he said, “but Iran may find it necessary to break the blockade rather than allow its position to deteriorate over time.”
