Anthropic’s historic IPO, the largest in U.S. history, was a huge win for the company and its investors. But it failed in another challenge: reviving animal spirits in the AI industry.
The Nasdaq Composite Index closed down 2.25%, with the S&P 500 down 2% to 7,175, amid a broad market pullback.
It wasn’t supposed to turn out like this.
Investors were looking forward to Anthropic’s IPO as a “liquidation event.” The tech sector is coming back to life after months of volatile trading. Nvidia Spy scandals and the US government’s crackdown on potential export control violations are raising concerns that sales of AI chips to Asia could suffer.
Some of those concerns resurfaced Thursday after short seller Hunterbrook Media claimed in a report that the firmware was being sold by the chipmaker. AMD The incident was discovered at a company on the US blacklist. AMD stock closed down more than 7%. The chipmaker told CNBC it complies with U.S. law.
The House Foreign Affairs Committee added to the concerns by releasing documents showing that a branch of the Commerce Department had approved the sale of more than 879,000 AI chips to Chinese companies. This has increased the possibility that sales in Asia will slow down due to stricter export controls.
Many investors and analysts continue to express confidence in the AI industry, noting that Anthropic’s successful market debut (stock price up 17% from its IPO price, raising more than $81 billion) bodes well for capital spending across the technology.
But investors acknowledged that these are tense times and said it was time to be more strategic about trade.
Dan Niles, founder of Niles Investment Management, described himself as a “cautious bull” compared to 2022, when major indexes plummeted in the second half of the year.
“I could have still made money that year. All I needed was the right combination of longs and shorts,” he says.
Niles said part of the challenge is price competition between Anthropic and OpenAI, two cutting-edge frontier laboratories. This poses a threat to the overall revenue and profit potential of AI and the capital investment that goes into it. He points out that intense price competition is causing collective losses between the top two companies.
“OpenAI and Anthropic’s combined revenue growth was 48% in the third quarter, up from 75% in the second quarter,” he told CNBC. “From the second quarter to the third quarter, total losses increased from $7.9 billion to approximately $8.4 billion.”
While there is currently a lot of uncertainty, some resolution may be on the horizon as more commercial and regulatory clarity emerges in the coming months.
Trade experts also told CNBC on Thursday that the technology sector’s problems go deeper than just Anthropic siphoning money from other parts of the market.
“AI in general is undergoing a reset,” said senior vice president JJ Kinahan. .
He said that for years investors have profited by buying on the edge of tech stocks, but “there has been a shift in the mindset that you can’t just buy things blindly and everything is going to go up.” He said Nvidia’s continued decline has shaken his confidence in the buy-on-the-dip strategy.
The next few trading days for Anthropic will be a key indicator of market strength. Friday will be a “wild card”, Kinahan said. It could be a “final flushout” of the market, or a rebound that leaves the market in “no man’s land” with volatility remaining high.
A better judge may be Monday, when Anthropic options trading begins. This will provide insight into whether retail investors substantively support the company, providing an additional vote of confidence in AI trading.
“If you think we’re going to go up (in Anthropic), you’ll buy the stock, but especially retail, you’ll just buy the calls,” he said. “We have a bigger test on Monday.”
For now, investors continue to sell AI stocks.
Neoclouds, an AI-only computing provider on the fringes of the AI industry that typically carries heavy debt, fell sharply on Thursday, with CoreWeave closing more than 6%.
alphabet and Amazon.comconsidered a relatively defensive AI bet, also ended lower.
There is one bright spot. Cybersecurity stocks continue to rise. palo alto networks and both closing up. AI is discovering security holes across software infrastructure, sparking a scramble to patch vulnerabilities before hackers can exploit them.
— CNBC’s Daren Fonda contributed reporting.
