
Clothing isn’t made the way it used to be, and more shoppers are paying attention.
The composition of apparel imported into the United States has changed in recent years. In 2010, approximately 60% of clothing was made primarily from cotton. Currently, that total is about 45%, with synthetic fibers, mainly polyester and nylon, accounting for the bulk of imports.
Apparel prices generally fell in the two decades leading up to the pandemic, according to the Consumer Price Index. Since 2020, it has soared to an all-time high.
Consumer habits are starting to change, with consumers paying more for food, gas, rent, and other necessities. Shoppers are paying more for clothing and are looking to make sure the clothing is worth the cost.
The 2026 Consumer Sentiment Index, which surveyed more than 9,000 shoppers by consulting firm AlixPartners, found that consumers are scrutinizing labels more closely and rejecting cheaper materials that sell for a premium.
“If a product is not a natural material, retail brands that pass it off as something that is not natural are really cutting consumer interest,” said Sonia Lapinski, head of fashion at AlixPartners.
polyester shift
Fast fashion brands like Forever 21 and H&M exploded in popularity from the early 2000s to the 2010s, bringing trendy clothing quickly to shelves at low prices. Then along came superfast fashion, with brands like Shein and Fashion Nova bringing out new clothing even faster and at lower prices. This was made possible in part by the use of inexpensive synthetic fibers.
“We’ve reached a point where the pendulum has swung too far in that direction, and we’re really starting to see a reversal,” said Janine Stichter, consumer analyst at US Bancorp BTIG. “Quality has been more important in the last three or four years than it has been in the last 10 or 20 years.”
But shoppers often tie quality directly to materials, which can lead to higher costs.
According to data from the U.S. Department of Commerce’s Bureau of Textiles and Apparel, the average unit price of clothing imported into the United States from January to August was $2.64 per square meter for clothing made primarily of synthetic fibers such as polyester and nylon, compared to $3.67 per square meter for clothing made primarily of cotton.
Comparing the 2026 numbers to 2010, the cost of importing synthetic apparel increased by approximately 11%, while the cost of cotton apparel increased by 21%.
“If you want to appeal to more value-conscious customers, you’re going to either reduce quality, try to negotiate some of the costs with suppliers, or absorb the costs. You’re probably going to want to produce more of your product to compensate,” said Aneesha Sherman, senior retail analyst at Bernstein Research.
Polyester is cheaper, but experts say that’s not necessarily a bad thing. Helps keep clothes from losing their shape and wicks away sweat.
Polyester products workshop at the factory of Jiangsu Hengke New Materials Co., Ltd. in Tongzhou District, Nantong City, Jiangsu Province, China, September 15, 2026.
Photo | Future Publishing | Getty Images
Sherman believes the athleisure boom is a major factor in the shift to polyester. From 2015 to 2025, U.S. sports apparel growth was 4.9%, compared to 2.6% growth for overall apparel and footwear, she said, according to Euromonitor data.
“There’s probably a decline in quality there as well,” Sherman said. “But I think both of these trends are being mixed up.”
Nevertheless, the backlash against synthetic materials is growing. Gen Z has repurposed the word “polyester” as an insult, generally meaning low quality or fake.
A growing body of research shows that microplastics can leach from polyester clothing when laundered, and concerns about the environmental and human health surrounding petroleum-based clothing are also growing.
This has caused consumers to reconsider the materials in their clothing.
manufacturing industry movements
BTIG’s Stichter said apparel prices rose after the pandemic because demand outstripped supply, allowing companies to raise prices. Then came the tariffs and the Iran war, which raised costs for businesses and increased prices for consumers.
Oil is the raw material for many synthetic fibers, and oil prices have skyrocketed since the start of the Iran war.
The same factors that contributed to soaring clothing prices, such as coronavirus, tariffs, and war, also affected clothing quality.
“Companies have had to move their supply chains in the post-COVID period,” Stichter said. “They had to find ways to cut costs and in some cases use cheaper fabrics.”
These factors have exacerbated the shift away from manufacturing in China for more than a decade.
Shen Lu, a professor of fashion and apparel at the University of Delaware whose research focuses on the economics of the global textile industry, said China’s established history in garment production means it has more skilled workers, state-of-the-art equipment and better materials management compared to emerging manufacturing countries such as Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Cambodia.
“They primarily serve the value market and the mass market. And I think the reason why they’re not ready to make higher quality luxury or premium products is really a reflection of the kind of skill sets that you can expect when sourcing from these countries,” Lu said.
AlixPartners’ Lapinski said those countries with low-cost manufacturing may still have to ship raw materials from China, which could extend the timeline for clothing production. This means betting early on trends and discounting products if they don’t sell.
“If you have to lower the price of that product because consumers don’t want it as much, your net profit may actually be worse than if you just invested in quality to begin with,” BTIG’s Stichter said.
Stichter also said rising material costs for synthetic fibers could further influence companies to use more natural fibers in the future.
Abercrombie & Fitch 100% merino wool sweater.
Natalie Rice | CNBC
Who benefits?
In this environment, companies that prioritize quality are winning.
ralph lauren’s The stock price has increased about 85% over the past two years. According to the company’s 2026 sustainability report, approximately 90% of its apparel is primarily made from cotton, leather, wool, viscose, cashmere and silk. The company said it sold more products at full price and reduced markdowns in fiscal 2026.
Meanwhile, Quince, a direct-to-consumer clothing brand with natural materials at the center of its brand identity, was valued at $10 billion this year.
The brand rose 16 spots to No. 3 for highest resale value in online consignment retailer ThredUp’s 2025 report. Organic cotton retailer Pact jumps 20 places on that list to No. 8, demonstrating the material’s potential role in brand recognition.
Alternatively, a 2026 AlixPartners report that ranked sentiment towards brands in various retail categories found that shoppers viewed some fast fashion brands less favorably. Shane and Zara both dropped three places in terms of sentiment in the Young Adult specialty to fifth and seventh place respectively.
Imen Ben Youssef | AFP | Getty Images
Shein claimed he would pass on the tariff hike to shoppers in 2025, blaming subsequent sales declines on those higher prices. The super-fast fashion retailer saw its year-over-year share of U.S. apparel, accessories and footwear card spending decline in the fourth quarter of 2025 and the first two quarters of 2026, according to Consumer Edge.
Schein did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Although Zara fell down in AlixPartners’ Consumer Confidence Index, its sales and profits continued to increase year-on-year. Still, Lapinski said that even if the company is doing well, it’s important to keep an eye on the deterioration in consumer perceptions.
“What we’ve learned from using this consumer sentiment index over the years is that sometimes it’s a leading indicator of what’s to come,” said AlixPartners’ Lapinski. “I’m not saying this applies to ZARA, but I think it’s one of the things we’ll be looking at in the coming quarters and into 2027.”
