A Kalsi billboard displays odds for the U.S. Senate midterm elections, Friday, October 16, 2026, in New York, USA.
Michael Nagle | Bloomberg | Getty Images
The turf war between states and the federal government is intensifying after Democrats secured control of Congress and key state governorships on midterm election night.
Democrats were widely expected to tighten oversight of the multibillion-dollar emerging industry if they took control of Congress, but post-election action has largely come from Republican-led states.
At the same time, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the federal regulator for prediction markets, is increasing its oversight of the “mention” market, where traders guess what individuals will say during speeches or broadcasts. This is a type of event contract, which authorities say could be manipulated.
CNBC first reported Tuesday that the CFTC withheld market certification related to President Donald Trump’s comments in mid-November. Kalsi said it was complying with the order, but CEO Tarek Mansour said at an Axios event on Tuesday that the company disagrees with the regulator’s decision.
The Senate passed a bipartisan bill Thursday that would prohibit companies registered with the CFTC from posting contracts related to terrorism, assassination, war, or military operations. The measure also prohibits contracts that are “reasonably expected” to be resolved on the basis of an individual’s death.
Criminal charges, restraining orders, lawsuits
On October 28, Utah Attorney General Derek Brown filed 14 criminal charges against Carsi and its founders, Mansour and Luana López Lara, alleging that the company violated state laws banning gambling.
Kalsi’s founders are scheduled to appear in Utah’s Third District Court on December 4, according to court documents.
“This is an outrageous overreach. Utah is clearly playing politics, and we look forward to stopping this in court, just as we did in Arizona,” said Dani Lever, a spokeswoman for Calci.
In a separate civil suit on Oct. 20, the state of Utah also named institutional market maker Susquehanna International Group as defendants, along with Mr. Kalsi.
Arizona Attorney General Chris Mays filed criminal charges against Carsi in March, but a federal judge blocked the case from proceeding in April.
Louisiana’s Republican attorney general also filed a complaint on November 12 seeking to ban multiple exchanges from operating in the state, and a state judge issued a temporary restraining order against the prediction market companies on the same day.
“Who would have thought that these red states that were reluctant to jump into the litigation arena would end up with the boldest and most innovative solutions,” said gambling attorney Daniel Wallach, noting that recent cases in Louisiana and Utah were led by Republican attorneys general.
In response, the CFTC filed suit against Louisiana on November 13th. Separately, federal agencies also filed suit against the state of Arkansas after it pursued civil enforcement against Carsi.
The CFTC has sued 12 states, attempting to defend what it considers exclusive jurisdiction to regulate prediction markets.
Meanwhile, the CFTC may add new commissioners soon. President Donald Trump on Nov. 12 sent bipartisan nominees to the Senate to fill two of the four vacancies on the committee. Chairman Michael Selig has been the only member of the committee since his nomination was confirmed by the Senate in December 2025.
Republican Nathan Anonic and Democrat Matthew Rowland appeared before the Senate Agriculture Committee on Tuesday. Several senators asked questions about prediction markets. When asked if they considered sports-related event contracts to be gambling, both disagreed.
Calci loses at Maryland
The CFTC’s position faces another setback this week with a complicated ruling by the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals. The court ruled 2-1 that Maryland could enforce state gambling laws against Carsi, but the justices disagreed with that reasoning.
“The justices disagree about why we are wrong,” Calci spokeswoman Elizabeth Diana said in a statement about the decision. “This divided decision, which includes three different and contradictory opinions, shows that there is no unified and consistent legal argument against prediction markets.”
Overall, the prediction market currently has three losses and one win at the circuit court level. The question of whether states or the federal government can regulate sports-related event contracts is widely expected to be decided by the Supreme Court.
Donald Trump Jr. partes ways with Kalsi
Carsi ended her advisory relationship with Donald Trump Jr. on November 12th. The prediction platform noted that his venture capital firm 1789 Capital has a stake in rival platform Polymarket.
1789 Capital announced its stake in Polymarket in August, but Calci and the president’s son ended their relationship after Democrats secured a majority in both houses of Congress. Democratic lawmakers are expected to investigate companies with ties to the Trump family.
Nine Democratic senators, led by Adam Schiff (D-Calif.), sent a letter to the CFTC on Monday asking it to rescind its instructions to platforms not to geofence their services if they receive an unfavorable court ruling that prevents exchanges from operating in certain states.
Geofencing involves using location technology to block users within a particular jurisdiction from participating in an event contract.
“Your unilateral decision directly conflicts with affirmative court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed,” the senators wrote.
Meanwhile, Democratic Rep. Ro Khanna (D-Calif.) called on Congress to completely ban sports-related prediction markets.
“Carsi, a $40 billion company, lets 18-year-olds bet on sports. They call it ‘prediction markets.’ It’s a gamble,” he wrote in a post to X on Wednesday. “Investigating and banning sports prediction markets.”
Disclosure: CNBC and Kalsi have a commercial relationship that includes customer acquisition and minority ownership.
