The operators of the Snikko technology used in the Ashes have admitted the mistake that led to Australia’s Alex Carey unfairly surviving the England review on the first day of the third Test.
Carey took Australia to 326-8 with a stunning maiden Ashes century, but for a moment it looked like the target might be out of reach when England immediately asked for a reconsideration after an appeal to take a catch behind Josh Tan’s bowling was rejected by umpire Ahsan Raza.
There was a noticeable noise when the ball passed the outside edge of the carry, and there was also a large spike in the Snicko technology used to aid in such decisions. However, television umpire Chris Gaffaney quickly ruled that the no-out call should be upheld because Snicko’s spike appeared before the ball reached the bat.
Carey, who had a 72 at the time of review, then shot 106, but admitted in the post-closing press conference that he thought he had done well.
Use Chrome Browser for a more accessible video player
Sky Sports’ Nasser Hussain talks about how England were able to reignite their Ashes hopes despite Alex Carey’s stunning century on the first day of the third Test in Adelaide.
Late Wednesday, BBG Sports, which owns Snikko, accepted responsibility for the mistake. The company acknowledged that the audio was incorrectly captured from the bowler’s stump microphone, resulting in a delay that caused audio spikes to be significantly out of sync with the image.
“Given Alex Carey’s admission that he hit the ball in question, the only conclusion that can be drawn from this is that Snicco’s operators at the time must have chosen the wrong stump microphone for audio processing,” BBG Sports said.
“In light of this, BBG Sports accepts full responsibility for this error.”
It remains to be seen how important this moment will be, as England need a win to prevent Australia from staying in the Ashes after losing the first two Tests of the five-match series.
“I thought I heard a feather or something as it passed the bat,” Carey said before issuing a statement admitting error.
“If it had come out, I don’t think I would have had the confidence to look at it again. The sound of it going through the bat sounded good.”
Use Chrome Browser for a more accessible video player
Alex Carey has given a cheeky response if he was a ‘pedestrian’ following his controversial not-out call during the third Ashes Test.
England bowling coach David Saker also suggested that tourists may feel the need to lodge formal complaints with match officials over concerns about the technology before the mistake is confirmed.
“I don’t think we’ve done anything about it so far, but after today we might make a little bit more progress,” Saker, who carried out England’s media duties after Wednesday’s play, said.
“There were concerns about that throughout the series. You shouldn’t be talking about this after playing a day. You should be better than that. That’s the reality.”
Carey finished first Ashes century
In the first Test, there was a significant controversy over Snicko when England wicketkeeper Jamie Smith was caught behind and out despite a small spike that was out of sync with the ball passing through the bat.
Officials justified the decision by explaining that the technology can result in a two-frame gap between the image and the sound waves.
England declined to comment further after confirming the operational error.
Finn calls for end of Snikko | Others support TV referee
Former England bowler Stephen Finn was a vocal critic of the series, calling for the technology to be scrapped.
A more advanced version of this technology, UltraEdge, is used in other countries, including England, to assist with referee reviews.
Use Chrome Browser for a more accessible video player
Flashback to one of the most memorable Ashes moments, Stuart Broad refusing to walk during the 2013 Ashes.
“The Ashes series usually ends people’s careers, but when this series ends, it could be the end of Snicco’s career,” Finn told TNT Sports.
“We had a terrible performance throughout the series. We had three or four incidents, so I hope they can step it up.”
Sky Sports’ Michael Atherton said he believed the technology led to the wrong call, but said the third umpire had no choice but to call it a no-out.
England eventually dismissed Carey for 106
Atherton told the Sky Sports Cricket Podcast: “The call is not an out so the third umpire has to have confidence that he can overturn the call based on the evidence in front of him.”
“I think the third umpire made the only decision because the footage of the spike and the ball passing through the bat were so far apart.
“I think the regulations say if it’s one frame off, it’s OK, you can do it. But it was off by a lot, so I don’t know what the third official can do.”
Ashes Series in Australia 2025-26
Australia leads series 5 games 2-0
