An Amazon driver loads a package into a delivery van at an Amazon delivery station in Alpharetta, Georgia, on November 28, 2022.
Justin Sullivan | Getty Images
Amazon is using its shopping website and app to fight New York City’s delivery bill, supported by Mayor Zoran Mamdani.
Some users who opened the company’s shopping app or website reported seeing pop-ups or banners warning them that if the New York City Council passed Intro 518, they “could be subject to additional charges of up to $5 per order.”
The bill would require Amazon to directly hire a number of third-party delivery companies, disrupting the contractor model the company has relied on since 2018. To speed up deliveries and manage more logistics operations, Amazon uses a network of thousands of small businesses, often working exclusively for Amazon, to handle the last mile portion of shipments.
“If this bill passes, we will not be able to work with them and will be forced to consider moving our operations out of town,” Amazon’s in-app message says. “That would likely make deliveries to millions of New York City customers slower and more expensive, while also threatening small businesses and their thousands of employees.”
The bill was introduced in February and is awaiting review by City Council President Julie Menin.
Amazon also posted a statement on its website, where it frequently publishes its policy views. But the company rarely leveraged its valuable e-commerce site and app assets to boost its prospects. Other technology companies Uber and lift We’ve used the app in the past to advocate for and against legislation as well.
Amazon’s pop-up notification and sticky banner on the store’s homepage directs users to a form where they can “contact your City Council member to oppose Intro 518.”
Amazon said 20,000 customers emailed city council members in the first six hours after the pop-up appeared.
Menin told CNBC in a statement that Amazon’s argument that the bill would force it to raise prices “defies logic.”
“We are crafting legislation that would regulate Amazon and protect workers without affecting prices or jobs,” Menin said. “If Amazon thinks this deceptive campaign will effectively blackmail New Yorkers and intimidate this City Council, they are dead wrong.”
Amazon spokeswoman Kelly Nantel said in a statement that the company posted the notice to “be transparent with our customers” about how the bill would “impact them if passed as written.”
“If a customer is concerned, one of the most impactful things they can do is contact their city council member and ask them to oppose this bill,” Nantel said.
The Shipping Protection Act has received significant support from labor groups such as the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, which has sought to unionize Amazon delivery drivers and warehouse workers.
Mamdani supported the bill in August, saying Amazon’s subcontracting model “makes workers vulnerable and gives companies free rein to avoid responsibility for reckless conditions on our streets.” He has argued that the bill would lead to safer working conditions for drivers and allow cities to “regulate last-mile operations.”
Amazon disputed Mamdani’s claims, saying the bill would “put the jobs of delivery service partners at risk without improving safety.” He also claimed that other companies and governments use contractors for their work, and said the DSP model has enabled them to meet growing customer demand.
Amazon said it works because “local entrepreneurs, people who are rooted in the community, provide a better experience.” “They’re investing in their teams, their routes, their neighborhoods. It’s not about accountability.”
Amazon has lobbied heavily against the bill, while logistics and business groups have run local advertising campaigns and threatened to sue the city if the bill passes.
