Following the US midterm elections, all eyes are on whether Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth will be able to maintain his cabinet-level position after a new Democratic majority in Congress takes office.
The Fox News host turned military chief is already facing growing calls for his removal.
Recommended stories
list of 4 itemsend of list
But analysts question the extent to which Hegseth’s impeachment will affect military policy under President Donald Trump.
“At the end of the day, the secretary of defense is a powerful participant in shaping war,” said Jasmine El Gamal, a former Pentagon Middle East adviser.
But El-Gamal believes that targeting Hegseth alone is not enough to ensure accountability for US-Israeli decisions such as starting a war against Iran.
She explained that although Hegseth holds significant power in directing the U.S. war effort, he works in tandem with the president and his advisers.
“To call him just an ‘executor’ understates his power, while to call him its sole architect understates the president’s power and obscures where certain decisions were actually made,” El-Gamal said.
Since taking office on January 25, 2025, Mr. Hegseth has overseen some of President Trump’s most controversial international campaigns, including the war against Iran and a series of deadly ship attacks in the Caribbean and eastern Pacific Ocean.
Both campaigns have been accused of violating international law. The Iran war in particular posed a political challenge for President Trump’s Republican Party during the midterm elections.
In a poll earlier this month, 44% of American voters said they were unlikely to vote for a midterm election candidate who supported the war.
This number dwarfed the 13% who said they were more likely to vote for such a candidate by a more than 3-to-1 ratio.
Democrats won a landslide victory in the November 3 midterm elections, flipping both houses of Congress from Republican control.
Less than a week later, Hegseth faced an impeachment push led by outgoing Republican Rep. Thomas Massey.
Among the eight articles of impeachment introduced by Massi were accusations that Hegseth dismantled basic safeguards to protect civilian lives and led to incidents such as the bombing of an elementary school in Minab, Iran, which killed at least 120 children.
However, impeachment proceedings were shelved on November 10 after the Republican lame-duck majority in the House blocked the bill by a vote of 211-204. Eleven Democratic members were absent from the vote.
Hegseth is not the first Pentagon chief to face pressure to resign following his party’s crushing defeat.
In November 2006, Republicans suffered a similar midterm election defeat amid growing voter anger over the U.S.-led wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. That year, both chambers of Congress came under Democratic control.
Within a day of the vote, then-President George W. Bush announced that the late Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld would resign. He mentioned the Iraq war in his remarks.
President Bush said of the conflict: “We recognize that many Americans voted last night to express their frustration with the lack of progress.”
But Hegseth has resisted calls to resign. In a five-minute video posted two days after the midterm elections, Hegseth dismissed his critics as “deep state radicals” obsessed with “political theater.”
“They attack us because we’re effective. That doesn’t work. We won’t back down,” Hegseth said. “We always, and without apology, put America and our warfighters first, and that fight continues in this lame duck Congress.”
His defiant message included an appeal for the military to “stay the course”, including in the war against Iran.
“I assure you, we have only just begun the fight,” Hegseth added. “We are more determined than ever and determined to finish what we started.”
But some of the criticism comes from within Hegseth’s own party. For example, Vice President J.D. Vance said that the “real reason” Republicans lost the midterm elections was “clear to almost everyone.”
“The reason we lost is the war,” he wrote on social media.
Hala Harit, a former U.S. diplomat who worked at the State Department for 18 years, was among the staffers who resigned before President Trump took office for his second term in protest of U.S. involvement in Israel’s genocidal war in Gaza.
She explained that Hegseth would have played a key role in guiding some of the most divisive moments of the Iran war.
For example, the Minab Elementary School bombing occurred on February 28, the first day of the conflict.
Lalit said Hegseth and other Pentagon officials would have drawn up an initial hit list before advising Trump on goals for final approval.
“I think Mr. Trump will not go into details about which targets he will attack on the first day,” Lalit told Al Jazeera.
“Hegseth and others at the Department of Defense are heavily involved in making these exact decisions, and that’s through their lawyers as well.”
She also drew a line between the decisions Hegseth and Trump made and the losses the United States and its allies have endured since the war began.
Iran has carried out attacks across the Middle East in retaliation for attacks by the United States and Israel. At least 23 U.S. military personnel were killed and 865 injured in the conflict.
“Ultimately, both countries are responsible not only for the attack on Iran, but for the exploitation of American military personnel and diplomats throughout the region,” Lalit said.
Brian Finucane, who served as State Department general counsel from 2011 to 2021, said Congress had the power throughout the war to pull the emergency cord and stop fighting.
He said that under the Constitution, “the vast majority of war powers vest in Congress.”
He sees the interim results in part as a reaction to the Trump administration’s expansive use of executive power.
Ultimately, critics say, officials like Mr. Hegseth provide little transparency to Congress about the military’s overseas actions.
“We’ve seen something like the culmination of presidential unilateralism under the Trump administration,” Finucane said. “I think it reminded the American people why this Constitution gives Congress the power to lead the country into war, not just one person.”
The incoming Democratic-led Congress has vowed to use its powers to rein in Trump’s ability to wage war and confront Hegseth over his policies.
In the final days of the midterm campaign, Democratic Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, who is running to become the first black speaker of the House, told supporters that Mr. Hegseth did not have long to live.
“In the vast majority of cases, one of the first things we’re going to do is get Pete Hegseth out of town,” Jeffries said.
He has since said he is “firmly in favor” of impeachment proceedings against the Pentagon chief.
But El-Gamal cautioned against treating an impeachment vote as the only path to accountability.
“Impeachment is just one of the constitutional accountability mechanisms,” El-Gamal said.
She cited Congressional investigations and Congress’ “power of the purse” (Congress’ authority over federal spending) as two other tools to rein in Mr. Hegseth and Mr. Trump.
El-Gamal added that the impeachment motion that was blocked in November was “not an acquittal or a vote to resolve the allegations” for war crimes in Iran and elsewhere. She expects the new Congress to continue pursuing these allegations after taking office.
