This week, Saturday Night Live’s skit “Sister” became a hot topic for its satire on family relationships surrounding caring for the elderly. I’m sure I’m not the only one who watched this with a bit of a sense of discomfort.
In the sketch, cartoonist John Mulaney pitches men a free 24/7 system for caring for their aging parents: your sister. “Now I don’t have to worry about my dad getting the care and attention he needs. My sister takes care of it, and I can get back to living my life and doing the things I love.”
It’s funny because it’s true. Study after study shows that daughters are more likely than sons to be caregivers for their elderly parents and tend to spend far more time on caregiving responsibilities, often with a negative impact on their careers.
I’m here to tell you that my parents are doing very well. They are spending their retirement golfing and traveling, and have just downsized their homes to make aging easier.
But that sketch revealed an uncomfortable truth. I might have thought that if something were to happen and one or both of us needed one of our kids to help take care of it, maybe my sister would take the lead.
On paper it makes sense! She still lives nearby. I have moved. She owns a house with multiple bedrooms. I’m renting a one-room apartment. She is a former real estate attorney and is experienced in handling all legal matters related to estate matters and end-of-life planning. I…I’m not.
But this doesn’t happen on paper. This is real, and what SNL so well satirizes is that without real communication, someone can default to a role they don’t really want.
“I love my mom more than anything, but that doesn’t mean I want to help her use the bathroom,” SNL star Andrew Dismukes tells the camera. “My ‘sister’ doesn’t either; she does, but I don’t.”
Call your sister…
So I sent the sketch to my sister and then called her. When she picked up the phone, we both said, “No!” Just kidding.
But it became clear that we both felt the same way about the personal and, in some cases, financial sacrifices we would make to care for our parents. I hope that doesn’t happen. If so, I am confident that we both will be able to provide them with excellent care. But neither of us are like champions with bits.
It also became clear that neither of us really knew what our parents wanted. Would they want to live with any of us? Would you prefer a professional nurse or a home health aide to provide your care? We had no idea.
My sister knew the general terms of their will, but she didn’t know if there was a long-term care policy. We both had some ideas about how we might or might not want our parents to live out their retirement years, but we had never seriously discussed it with them. Not only about the wishes of the parents, but also about their assets.
Regarding the latter point, my sister told me, wearing her lawyer’s hat, that the situation depicted in the sketch was all too common. As SNL star Kenan Thompson says in the sketch while lying down in resort wear, “Your parents were born before dementia, so ‘Sister’ won’t change your inheritance. You’ll receive 50% of the house she’s currently cleaning.”
I asked my sister if people tend to change their estate plans to account for children making labor and other sacrifices to raise them.
“If they have thought about it and can do it at or before the time they need care,” she told me. Some families may gift money to children in their care during their lifetime or leave more in a will, she said. “I’ve even seen people give their children a home if they move in with them.”
As far as I’m concerned, it’s all on the table. And we need to keep talking about this with each other and with our parents.
…and a financial psychologist
Megan McCoy, a Kansas State University professor and financial therapist, says it’s smart for my sister and I to intervene in these conversations now that everyone is happy, healthy, and independent.
“Having these conversations early on, before someone gets sick, is the greatest gift a family can have,” she told me.
Conversations about money, death, and inheritance are always difficult, so McCoy suggests starting small. “We’re not trying to tackle everything at once. We’re just trying to start a conversation,” she says. “You might start by asking them about their experiences caring for their parents, or you could ask them to look back and think about what they’re most proud of. Then slowly get into specifics.”
The goal, she says, is transparency. Perhaps your parents prefer a professional caregiver rather than a family member. If so, you might want to find out if they have money set aside for that possibility, or if it’s something you or your generation need to help financially.
When it comes to siblings, the conversation revolves around the division of roles, and you may find that you can share caregiving responsibilities equally. McCoy says it’s important to recognize that caregiving can be both financially and emotionally taxing if one person has to take a more active role. And being there to help one side or the other makes things less stressful and avoids the kind of unspoken grudges that SNL makes fun of. If one sibling is contributing more money, the other may become a sounding board for the parents or delve deeper into prescribing research, she suggests.
“It’s about analyzing all the different ways we support people and saying, ‘How can we analyze this and take some of the burden off your shoulders?’
Overall, do your best to have short conversations about these topics early and often. Think of it as getting “reps,” McCoy says. This takes the pressure off everyone and allows decision-making to be handled more organically, she says.
“Don’t expect this big emotional leap in Conversation 1,” she says. “It probably won’t happen until conversation 60.”
