It’s been a wonderful year. Or maybe you’ve been through something terrible. Either way, you’ll be gathering with friends and family during the holidays.
You may wonder how much you should be open about your own successes and setbacks, and how much you should ask about the other person’s successes and setbacks.
As a social psychologist, I’ve long been interested in why it’s so difficult to understand what to share and what to keep secret. That question inspired me to write “Shall I Say Something?” A research-backed guide to help people make those decisions.
Research shows that you can probably be more candid than you think when it comes to holiday conversations, although there are some caveats.
Be sensitive to sharing good news without downplaying your successes
If you’re worried about hurting someone’s feelings, arousing envy, or sounding like you’re bragging, you may downplay or hide your successes.
But sharing good news makes you feel even better about what happened and brings you closer to the people you’re sharing it with. Having someone there for you when things go well is an important form of social support.
Our success also makes those close to us proud. When you share the good news, your relatives will brag about what their cousins and nieces are doing. Researchers call this “basking in reflected glory.”
Of course, some people may feel a little jealous. But that’s not necessarily a bad thing. Envy can take the form of admiration. It may even encourage your friends and family to follow your instructions instead of resenting you.
Some people may have mixed feelings about your good news. it’s okay. People can be proud of you and at the same time feel a little envious or resentful of you. Especially if you have achieved something that you desired for yourself but was out of reach.
But that’s no reason to hide or downplay your success. If they hear the news later, they may feel hurt that you didn’t tell them. Also, trying too hard to sound humble can come across as insincere. So share your good news carefully and give people room to feel however they like.
Be honest about the challenges of this year. the reaction may surprise you
It can be embarrassing to say you’ve been rejected, fired, or are on the move from every graduate program you applied to. What would that conversation look like? What will people think?
Research shows that people often respond better than we expect. One study found that people who shared their fears and anxieties were liked more than expected. They even made a better impression than people who shared neutral or positive information about themselves.
When deciding whether or not to open up about our insecurities, we tend to focus on what’s embarrassing. But those we choose to share with also learn that we are honest and trust them enough to share, qualities that people really like.
Does that mean Thanksgiving dinner should be dominated by sad stories? Of course not. No one wants to be Debbie Downer at the dinner table.
In a study of couples who successfully resolved their differences, psychologist John Gottman and his colleagues identified a “magic ratio” of about five positive interactions for every negative one.
I recommend borrowing that idea for Thanksgiving. Once you have the courage to reveal how you got fired, try keeping the conversation a little lighter before telling everyone how your apartment was broken into.
Think about whether and why you would ask that personal question.
If your cousin tells you that this year has been tough, you might say that you’re sorry to hear that and leave him alone. Why not ask, “What’s going on?” Research shows that people who ask more follow-up questions are more likable.
We tend to think it’s safer to talk about lawn care or the weather than to ask about family relationships or finances. But research shows that asking sensitive questions is less awkward than you might expect, and asking personal questions can lead to more intimate conversations.
But before you ask personal questions, be honest with yourself about why you want to ask. Are you asking out of a genuine desire to connect, or are you asking to satisfy your own curiosity?
In other words, do you really want to know what’s going on in your cousin’s life, or do you just want to know how much money they make?
The same goes for questions about a person’s appearance. If you first notice that your uncle’s weight has changed since you last saw him, it’s best to keep that observation to yourself and ask him about his uncle rather than his weight.
You may be hesitant to tell your loved ones something during the holidays. But remember, they’re probably more willing than you think to celebrate with you, support you through difficult times, and let you know how things are really going.
Vanessa Bohns is a social psychologist and author of Should I Say Something? The Science of What to Share—and What to Keep to Yourself. Mr. Bones is the Brownstein Family Professor and chair of the Department of Organizational Behavior at Cornell University’s ILR School. She has a Ph.D. in Psychology from Columbia University and a BA from Brown University.
