At a frigid Moscow airport, Steve Witkoff, a billionaire real estate developer and one of President Donald Trump’s top envoys, answered a brief question from a CNN team as he was ushered onto the tarmac.
Yes, Witkov said there had been “progress” in his meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin that day.
“This is what President Trump wants,” he added, hinting at how eager the US leader is to win a diplomatic victory in a brutal five-year conflict that he once boasted would be over in a day.
That progress is European involvement.
For nearly two years, Europe has been effectively sidelined in negotiations with Russia to achieve peace in Ukraine. But after Witkoff and Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, met with President Putin in Moscow on Thursday, the Russians appeared to have agreed to give Europe a seat at the negotiating table, something Moscow had so far resisted.
The move was welcomed by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, who has increasingly relied on European military, diplomatic and financial support to keep his country afloat and keep Russian forces at bay.
“It’s important that next time, next meeting, Europe is part of the negotiating team, not elsewhere, not separately. They will have a say,” Zelenskiy told reporters in Ireland after being briefed by Kushner and Witkoff at the European summit.
“This is important for us because the war is being fought in Europe. It is very important because we will be a member of the European Union in the future. For prosperity and security, it is very important to have Europe,” Zelenskiy added.
Although European countries are deeply skeptical of Russia’s willingness to find a diplomatic solution to ending the war in Ukraine, they see the inclusion of a European element in any future peace negotiations as a positive step and a long-standing recognition that the U.S. government cannot solve it alone.
“After almost two years of talks between the United States and Russia, I think both countries have realized that Europe has a big role to play here,” the EU’s top diplomat, Kaja Kallas, said in Dublin.
“We are the ones who have supported Ukraine, we are the ones who have introduced sanctions, we are the ones who have frozen (Russian) assets, so obviously without us they cannot implement any agreements there,” she added.
The composition of the European delegation is the subject of intense domestic debate. On Friday, European Council President Antonio Costa said the European team would be represented by EU institutions and the E5 countries of France, Germany, Italy, Poland and the United Kingdom.
Earlier, Kushner emphasized that it might be difficult for Europe to “identify one person to speak on its behalf,” saying that doing so “would be a bigger accomplishment than just having Russia bring them into the negotiations.”
While the formal involvement of European negotiators may be praised in Kiev and Brussels, it will not necessarily hasten an end to the conflict, which is estimated to have killed hundreds of thousands of people on both sides.
In subsequent remarks, Russia did not admit that it had fully agreed to Europe’s participation at the table. At a regular briefing on Friday, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said Europe needed to demonstrate a “willingness to contribute to the peace process” before deciding to join future negotiations.
European leaders routinely take a tough, moralistic stance toward Moscow, often demanding that Russia be defeated and punished for launching a full-scale invasion of Ukraine, and that the Kremlin withdraw its troops from all Ukrainian territory.
If these mantras are simply repeated at the negotiating table and a more realistic compromise does not emerge from Europe, as the Kremlin has suggested, a breakthrough with the Kremlin will become even less likely.
“They (Europeans) have to decide whether they want peace or a continuation of the war. So far, all their actual actions point precisely to the latter,” Yuri Ushakov said at a press conference after the meeting in Moscow.
And there are early signs that the Russian government, which has agreed to accommodate European negotiators, is already doubling down on its extremist demands for an end to the war, reinstating calls for NATO to withdraw from Eastern Europe and even pursuing the question of possible sending peacekeepers to monitor a ceasefire on the front lines.
“The solution that the US government and President Trump have to offer is to reach an agreement on future arrangements for pan-European security. And what are we hearing from the Europeans? They are saying no. Only after the Ukraine peace deal is reached,” Putin told Witkov and Kushner in a televised snapshot of the meeting.
“But after a peace agreement is reached in Ukraine, they are going to send troops… and that means a continuation of the war. So this is a vicious cycle,” Putin continued.
This is a sign that, even if it does not welcome European participation in negotiations, the Kremlin will find ways to exploit this new reality to try to achieve its objectives in Ukraine, especially by prolonging further negotiations while attacking Ukrainian cities.
Another winter of bitter conflict, one final push, is perhaps what the Kremlin really wants.
