Activists hold anti-China placards and flags during a protest in a park in Manila, June 18, 2019. Last week, a Chinese fishing boat sank in the disputed South China Sea and collided with a fleeing Philippine fishing boat, sparking outrage. Photo credit: TED ALJIBE/AFP) (Photo credit: TED ALJIBE/AFP, Getty Images)
Ted Aljibe | AFP | Getty Images
One of the world’s most disputed bodies of water continues to pose problems for Asia’s leaders.
Experts told CNBC that a substantive code of conduct in the South China Sea does not appear to be achievable, despite ASEAN countries expressing optimism that negotiations could be finalized after more than two decades.
The ASEAN summit in the Philippines failed to resolve the issue, even though Manila said it intended to conclude the code by the end of this year.
The crux of the problem is that China claims virtually the entire South China Sea as its territory, despite international rulings and historical claims by many other countries to the contrary.
China’s nine-dash line claim was ruled invalid by the Permanent Court of Arbitration in 2016, but the Chinese government has refused to recognize that ruling.
This illustration taken on March 19, 2025 shows a nine-dash line on a map of disputed areas in the South China Sea on a laptop in Lao Cai province.
Nhac Nguyen | AFP | Getty Images
China has been building structures to strengthen its territorial claims for decades, becoming increasingly aggressive in guarding its territory against countries such as the Philippines that claim traditional rights to its waters.
The South China Sea Code of Conduct aims to address an area where multiple ASEAN countries and China have disputes and competing claims.
Manila reported that it has completed 80% of the negotiating text and will continue negotiations under Singapore’s incoming ASEAN chair. But experts are skeptical that a “substantive and effective” agreement can be reached, at least in the short term.
“This is an annual ritual. ASEAN chairmen have promised to finalize the code of conduct in January, but by November they’re reporting that while they’ve made great progress, they haven’t gotten that far this year. Wash, repeat,” Ray Powell, executive director of the Seawright Foundation, a gray zone activity tracker, told CNBC.
He said the 80% figure was a “meaningless statistic” given the complexity and controversial nature of the issue at hand.
ASEAN Secretary-General Khao Kim Horn believes there is still a possibility of a resolution. “I don’t think it’s a failure at all,” he told CNBC’s JP Ong. “It still takes a lot of commitment and a lot of leadership on both sides to move forward and get it done.”

But Colin Koh, a senior fellow at the Institute for Defense Strategic Studies at Nanyang Technological University in Singapore, told CNBC that even if 80% of the text is finalized, the remaining 20% contains the most persistent issues such as geographic scope, conflicts of interest among ASEAN member states, and enforcement.
Koh said the original aim was for ASEAN to negotiate “one-on-one” with China, but that did not actually happen.
“It’s always been 10-1. If you add Timor-Leste to it, it’s 11-1. So there will never be a unified ASEAN position that would bring China to the negotiating table,” he said.
Disputes in the South China Sea date back to at least the 1970s, with countries including Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines and Vietnam claiming various areas and islands in the vital region, which is rich in natural resources and fishing grounds.
“It’s not likely to happen.”
Back in 2015, Singapore positioned itself as a “neutral mediator” in the ASEAN-China dialogue, with then-Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong saying it would “deal fairly and openly with all parties” to “protect peace and stability in the region”.
“China does not really want a code of conduct and is moving more aggressively into the South China Sea.”
Joshua Kurlanczyk
Council on Foreign Relations, Senior Fellow for Southeast and South Asia
But while the city-state may be able to broker some compromise, the disagreements that have maintained the norm for nearly a quarter of a century will continue, said Lin Kuok, Lee Kuan Yew director of Southeast Asian studies at the Brookings Institution.
“Furthermore, China has little incentive to accept meaningful restrictions while continuing to strengthen its position in the South China Sea,” Kuok added.
Joshua Kurlanczyk, senior fellow for Southeast Asia and South Asia at the Council on Foreign Relations, echoed his views, saying a code of conduct is unlikely to be enacted soon, if at all.
“China doesn’t really want a code of conduct and is moving more aggressively into the South China Sea,” he said, pointing to Beijing’s actions toward the Philippines in the region, including around the disputed Scarborough Shoal.
A Chinese Coast Guard vessel was recently suspected of ramming a Philippine fishing boat near the Spratly Islands in September, and has used lasers and water cannons against Philippine vessels in the past.
Kurlanczyk also said that there are several countries in ASEAN that are close to China and are prepared to maintain any agreement on norms, adding that the move toward China comes amid uncertainty about U.S. defense efforts in the region.
“I don’t think there’s actually a chance that a code of conduct will be enacted by Singapore as the ASEAN chair. Or, I don’t think there’s any possibility that a code of conduct will actually materialize as the ASEAN chair,” he said.
At the same time, Powell said if the code is rushed or flawed, it’s probably worse than nothing at all.
“In fact, the worst outcome is not a failure of the agreement, but rather weak norms that allow Beijing to undermine the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea,” he said. The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, which entered into force in 1994, provides a comprehensive legal framework for the world’s oceans and oceans.
“Then China’s argument could be, ‘Look, we’ve got a shiny new regional deal that overrides a questionable law invented by outsiders who don’t understand East Asia, and we shouldn’t have a say here anyway,'” Powell added.
—CNBC’s Joanna Ossinger contributed to this article.
