Democrat Mary Peltola defeated two-term Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan to win Alaska’s Senate seat. This is the first time in more than 10 years that a Democrat has won the state’s Senate.
As of early Wednesday morning, the Associated Press tally gave Sullivan 50.1% of the first-choice vote and 45.8% for Sullivan, with an estimated 99% vote count.
Recommended stories
list of 3 itemsend of list
It is important to clear the 50% mark. Alaska uses ranked-choice voting, which means that the candidate who receives a majority of first-choice votes is elected outright without further counting.
The vote is attracting attention not only because it is the last Senate race to be called in the midterm elections, but also because Republicans are legally challenging the election over a slate of candidates with nearly identical names: Republican Dan Sullivan and independent Daniel Sullivan. The legal challenge was dismissed days before the election.
The Trump administration has alleged that Peltola’s campaign intentionally used a second candidate, Dan Sullivan, to polarize the Republican vote in the state, a practice known as “vote stacking.”
But on Tuesday, it was clear that even if “official” Dan Sullivan received all of his namesake votes, he would not have received enough votes to defeat Peltola.
With Peltola’s victory, Democrats now hold 56 seats in the Senate, to Republicans’ 44.
Who is Mary Peltola?
Peltola, a Yup’ik Alaskan, won a special election for the state’s only House seat in 2022, becoming the first Alaskan to serve in Congress. She served from September 2022 to January 2025, but lost re-election in 2024.
In this year’s Senate campaign, he downplayed the Democratic label, which remains unpopular in the state, and focused on local issues such as energy jobs, border security and gun rights.
Scott Lucas, a professor of international politics at the Clinton Institute at University College Dublin, told Al Jazeera that Peltola is considered a “safe pair.”
“Alaska has a very small population and is a very large country, so it’s very important that we try to build bonds and community ties across that vast landmass,” he said. “Peltola was seen as a good representative of Alaska’s interests.”
Lucas described her as “a realist right in the middle of Democratic politics.” “It’s not too provocative and it’s not really playing identity politics,” he says. “She didn’t have the idea that this was all about Native Americans, even though she happened to be Native American.”
By contrast, Sullivan was “kind of a local candidate,” Lucas said, but “was hurt because he was on President Trump’s ticket, so to speak.” “If the Trump administration had done a better job on this issue, I think Mr. Sullivan would have kept his seat,” he added.
Why was this race so tense?
First, it was the last seat to be counted in the Senate.
But there were also two Dan Sullivans on the ballot.
In late May, Dan J. Sullivan, a retired teacher from St. Petersburg, entered the race. On June 15, the state Division of Elections removed him from the ballot. The paper said he chose the name to confuse him with senators and noted that he had hired a political consultant who previously worked for Peltola.
The court reversed that decision. A Superior Court judge ruled he was eligible, and the Alaska Supreme Court upheld that decision on June 29. The two candidates were listed on the ballot as independent Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. and incumbent Republican Dan S. Sullivan. The retired teacher finished in the top four in the August primary, earning him the right to appear on the November ballot.
Republicans claimed he was a decoy. The New York Times later reported that Peltola’s campaign staff and Democratic operatives lobbied him to run. At President Trump’s request, the Department of Justice (DoJ) sued to delay certification of Sen. Sullivan’s loss and to segregate the ballots cast for Sen. Sullivan. Federal Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case on November 1, but the Justice Department announced it would appeal.
Lucas said this type of “vote stacking” (supporting a leading candidate to draw votes from a rival) is not uncommon, and both parties have done it in the past. If the second-place candidate, Sullivan, had received 2% of the vote, he could have pushed the incumbent below 50% and forced a ranking vote, he said. “If you draw enough support from Republicans, you have a better chance of winning,” he said.
In the end, he said, “I don’t think it made that much of a difference.” Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. received 1.7% of the vote, while Peltola received more than 50% of the vote, according to an Associated Press tally.
Why is this result important?
Peltola will be the first Democrat to represent Alaska in the Senate since Sullivan defeated Mark Begich in 2014. Her victory is not the deciding factor in which party controls the chamber — Democrats already had enough seats to control the Senate — but Lucas said it is “important in a broader sense.”
Alaska is the latest of a series of Republican strongholds to switch to the Democratic Party.
On election night, Democrats flipped seats in North Carolina, South Carolina, Ohio, Texas, Kansas, Iowa, and Maine. The tallies that have since arrived confirm that Mississippi has reversed and elected its first black senator in 150 years, and Alaska brings the number to nine.
Texas went Democratic for the first time since 1988, and Kansas went Democratic for the first time since 1932.
“Alaska was one of the seats that we thought Democrats could win,” Lucas said. “So, in and of itself, it’s not as surprising as, say, Mississippi, but Mississippi is really, really surprising. South Carolina was pretty surprising as well. But it still reaffirms the extent of this Democratic surge.”
These wins also give Democrats a cushion. Senate terms are six years, and about a third of the 100 seats are up for grabs every two years, meaning seats won this month won’t be on the ballot again until 2032. Holding seats in states that Democrats don’t normally win could make it much harder for Republicans to retake the Senate in 2028.
Ultimately, this victory brings Democrats closer to the magical two-thirds majority. They currently hold 56 seats, Lucas said, “a sizable majority when even the most optimistic Democratic analysts were looking at 53 seats at most.” Republican support will still be needed to secure the two-thirds majority needed to override the president’s veto in both chambers.
Convicting officials in an impeachment trial requires a two-thirds vote in the Senate. The more seats Democrats hold, the fewer Republicans they need to win to reach that threshold. For now, Lucas said, “we can’t pass any legislation because President Trump can veto it. So if we want any legislation to pass, we still need to work with Republicans.”
What happens next?
Lucas expects the new Democratic majority to propose legislation and hold hearings on accountability for Trump and his family’s wealth, including cryptocurrencies, “whether it’s about AI or technology or the Epstein scandal.” “The Republican Party, on the other hand, is a divided party,” he said.
In North Carolina, South Carolina, and Texas, Trump’s aides pushed candidates to the party, resulting in defeat in all three states. In contrast, Democrats “wanted a more organic candidate, and Mary Peltola was one of them,” Lucas said.
“Diversity has become a bad word for the Trump campaign,” Lucas said. “What’s interesting is that in this very diverse election, we had the first Muslim senator in the United States, the first openly gay man in the United States to serve in the Senate, and two Native American women, Peggy Flanagan in Minnesota and then Peltola. In this case, the party with more diverse candidates did better.”
Lucas said Democrats will need to “show they can offer at least some chance of stability” before the 2028 presidential election, predicting that “the last few years will be pretty chaotic, largely because of the president.” Disputes over health insurance premium increases and data centers, which have proven unpopular in part because they waste local resources, are among the next challenges.
“This is no longer a question of right or left,” he said. “This is a question of who will govern effectively while in office.”
