Xavier Now | E+ | Getty Images
Homeowners who take out conventional loans and pay mortgage insurance are usually able to reduce their expenses once they have built up enough equity in their home to protect the lender from loss if the borrower defaults. But that’s not the case for people with Federal Housing Administration loans.
There was renewed push this week to change the rules governing mortgage insurance for FHA loans, after the Department of Housing and Urban Development released a report to Congress on Monday showing that the agency’s mortgage insurance fund remains in strong financial health. Its capital adequacy ratio, a measure of its financial cushion against potential losses, was 10.29% as of Sept. 30, down from 11.47% a year earlier, but still more than five times the minimum 2% required by Congress.
“The program’s financial strength provides an opportunity for targeted changes that improve affordability for borrowers while maintaining the long-term stability of FHA insurance funds,” Bob Bruksmit, president and CEO of the Mortgage Bankers Association, said in a statement after the report was published. The industry group was one of the few to issue a statement calling for change.
The push revives a long-standing desire in the mortgage industry and comes weeks after President Donald Trump issued an executive order that included a call for the start of a federal pilot program that would remove mortgage insurance on some conventional loans if the borrower meets capital requirements.
The order generally applies to future loans backed by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, government-backed companies that buy eligible mortgage loans from lenders and resell them as bundled securities. Does not apply to FHA loans.
Click here if you have an FHA home loan
Although FHA mortgages are issued by private lenders, they are guaranteed by the federal government, which protects the lender against loss if the borrower defaults. This loan is designed to make homeownership more accessible, especially for borrowers with limited down payment savings or bad credit.
Affordability challenges continue in the housing market, with rising home prices and mortgage rates putting homeownership out of reach for many prospective buyers. In addition to mortgages, existing homeowners also face rising costs such as property taxes and homeowners insurance amid generally high inflation.
In the most recent fiscal year, about 83% of new FHA purchase loans were made to first-time homebuyers, according to FHA’s report to Congress. As of September 30, FHA had insured more than 8.4 million total mortgages.
The median age of first-time buyers is 40, according to a new report from the National Association of Realtors.

FHA loans also require the borrower to pay mortgage insurance, regardless of the amount of the down payment. Under current rules, enacted in 2013, FHA borrowers with a down payment of less than 10 percent of the loan must pay mortgage insurance premiums for the life of the loan. Those who put down more than 10% will pay for the policy for 11 years.
Borrowers typically pay both an upfront mortgage insurance premium and an annual premium, which are usually split into monthly payments. The upfront premium is typically 1.75% of the base loan amount and can be financed as a mortgage. For many borrowers with 30-year FHA loans, the annual premium is 0.55% of the loan balance.
With conventional mortgages, mortgage insurance is usually not required unless the loan is for 80% or more of the home’s value. Premiums in 2022 typically ranged from 0.58% to 1.86% annually, according to Fannie Mae.
If such borrowers have to pay mortgage insurance, they can typically request that the insurance be canceled once they have 20% equity in their home, but the insurance is automatically canceled once the loan is down to 78% of its original value.
Proposals from the mortgage industry
The mortgage industry has announced two different proposals.
One would be to lower the interest rate applicable to FHA mortgage insurance. For example, the Mortgage Bankers Association recently proposed a 20 basis point rate cut, reducing the standard rate of 0.55% to 0.35% for new borrowers.
Example: For a $350,000 mortgage, an interest rate of 0.55% typically translates to $1,925 per year at loan origination, or about $160 per month. As a borrower’s monthly payments gradually reduce the debt principal over time, so does the amount of mortgage insurance.
At 0.35%, the annual premium would be $1,225 at the beginning of the loan, or $102 per month, a difference of $58 per month.
The FHA last lowered this rate in 2023, when it was lowered from 0.85%. At the time, HUD estimated that affected borrowers would save an average of $800 per year. But the FHA noted in a new report to Congress that the cuts in 2023 reduced the fund’s income and led to lower capital adequacy ratios.
Another industry proposal is to introduce automatic premium cancellation if the loan balance falls to 78% of the home’s original purchase price, similar to mortgages backed by Fannie and Freddie.
Cancellation avoids the squeeze on borrowers who pay off their loans and do not have to pay excess insurance premiums.
michael farrell
National Mortgage Brokers Association
“Cancellation prevents the squeeze on borrowers who have paid off their loans and should not be paying excess compensation,” said Michael Farrell, president of the National Association of Mortgage Brokers, an industry group that has generally supported cancellation proposals.
“NAMB believes that surrendering at 78% protects (FHA insurance funds) because premiums may resume if the (capital) ratio drops to 2%,” Farrell said.
FHA mortgages received that treatment from 2001 to 2013, but as funding reserves dwindled over time in the wake of the housing market crash that led to the 2008 financial crisis, FHA eliminated this treatment to shore up its insurance fund.
It is unclear whether this proposal will come to fruition. HUD, which oversees the FHA, did not respond to CNBC’s email seeking further information.
