
Major pizza chains are struggling as sales are weighed down by sluggish consumer spending, diversification of dining options, and an increase in GLP-1 treatment drugs.
The pandemic was a boom time. domino pizza, papa john’sLittle Caesars and Pizza Hut. But since dining rooms reopened, the nation’s largest pizza chain has faced an uphill battle to retain customers.
Consumers are being careful about their discretionary spending these days, and thanks to the accessibility of third-party platforms, they have more options for delivery and takeout when ordering. Additionally, food quality and customer experience have become more important to diners looking for value when ordering from restaurants.
Papa John’s International Inc. Pepperoni Pizza arranged on Monday, February 22, 2021 in Louisville, Kentucky, USA.
Luke Charette Bloomberg | Getty Images
As a result of pizza fatigue and the challenges facing the entire restaurant industry, the number of pizza restaurants in the United States has declined. More than 9,600 pizza restaurants have closed as of July 2026, since the number of pizza restaurants peaked at 83,035 nationwide in August 2019, according to data from Datassential.
U.S. pizza restaurant sales in 2025 decreased by 0.3%, according to data from Technomic. Sales at independent pizzerias decreased by 0.4%. Sales at chain stores, which account for about two-thirds of domestic pizza sales, fell 0.3%.
Papa John’s reported that same-store sales in North America decreased 2.5% in 2025. Pizza Hut’s U.S. same-store sales fell 5%. Of the three pizza chains that went public last year, Domino’s was the only one to post a 3% increase in annual same-store sales for its U.S. restaurants.
It’s not just diners who are losing their appetite for pizza. Since March 2020, Papa John’s stock has lost about two-thirds of its value. Even Domino’s Pizza, which dominates the category, saw its share price rise by only about 2% over that period. For comparison, S&P500 It rose about 150% over the same period.
An employee removes pizza from a pot at a Domino’s Pizza restaurant on Wednesday, April 10, 2024, in Trenton, Michigan. Domino’s Pizza is scheduled to announce its financial results on April 29th. Photographer: Nick Antaya/Bloomberg via Getty Images
Nick Antaya | Bloomberg | Getty Images
and yum brand sold Pizza Hut this year and moved its lagging portfolio to Long Range Capital and Yum China after nearly 20 years of weak sales.
“Pizza Hut has been disparaging YUM in the past…Moving forward, we expect YUM to be less constrained by pizza category trends (such as discounts) and more focused on stronger growth and higher-growth industry segments and markets,” Wells Fargo analyst Zachary Fadem wrote in a September research note.
pizza challenge
Pizza chains are currently facing significantly more competition for restaurant profits than in 2020. Third-party delivery platforms, which have grown in popularity during the pandemic, offer a wide range of cuisines beyond traditional pizza and Chinese food. As a result, Domino’s Pizza and Papa John’s are competing with other fast food chains such as McDonald’s and Chick-fil-A. door dash and Uber Eats instruction.
As pizza prices soar, pies seem to be less appealing to budget-conscious customers. The average price of a large cheese pizza is now about $17, according to industry publication PMQ Pizza’s 2026 Pizza Power Report.
Additionally, frozen pizza is a low-cost and convenient option. For the 52 weeks ending Nov. 7, retail sales of single and multi-serve frozen pizzas increased 2.9% compared to the same period in 2022, according to NielsenIQ data.
“When American consumers look to the cheapest dining opportunities, the items in my pantry, refrigerator, and freezer always win,” said David Portalatin, food and food service industry advisor at Circana.
Convenience stores, etc. Casey’s General Store The low-priced pizza also attracts customers.
“We believe (Casey’s) has an advantage over (quick-service restaurants) and dollar stores. While there are fewer options to weather a sustained inflation environment, (Casey’s) can offset food pressures with margins,” Sara Senatore, an analyst at Bank of America Securities, said in a June research note.
She added that the overlapping geographic locations suggest Casey’s is taking market share from Pizza Hut.
The largest pizza chains have also been slow to adapt to changing consumer attitudes toward nutrition. For example, of the four major chains, only Papa John’s is testing adding protein to its pizza dough, as more customers prioritize protein in their diets. And the test was conducted for just one day at one restaurant in Atlanta.
The broader nutritional profile of pizza is another hurdle for the category. The carbohydrate and fat content of dough and cheese, respectively, may make them less attractive to consumers of GLP-1 drugs, whose use has skyrocketed in recent years.
According to a 2026 study published by PwC, spending at pizza quick-service restaurants decreased by 22.2% per GLP-1 household after 6 to 8 months of drug use.
To be sure, pizza’s recent struggles don’t signify an existential crisis for the category. Chilcana’s Portalatin said total pizza offerings are down only about 1% this year.
And each chain store is trying to reverse this slump in the amount of service provided. In August, Domino’s Pizza launched Domino’s, a customizable Detroit-style personal pizza that appeals to single customers. In November, Papa John’s announced a new turnaround plan focused on improving food consistency and restaurant operations. And Pizza Hut is running a holiday-themed meal sale.
“Pizza isn’t going anywhere,” Portalatin said. “American consumers love pizza.”
